Editor's note: Throughout the Colorado Health Symposium, July 25-27, we provided a daily summary of news and insights through the Symposium Today blog posting.
Quote of the day:
"The fact that it's easier for a child to get a gun than health care is a fundamental problem." — Wes Moore, author of "The Other Wes Moore"
Moore energizes Symposium crowd
"You can't have an honest conversation about [national] debts and deficits unless you can have a conversation about health issues," said Wes Moore, author of the best-seller, "The Other Wes Moore" and Friday's keynote speaker. Moore's book examines many questions about personal responsibility, accountability, circumstance and choice, recurring themes of the 2012 Colorado Health Symposium. During the keynote, Moore eloquently correlated his experience with the challenges in health and health care discussed throughout the three-day conference. His remarks earned a standing ovation from the audience of about 400 people.
After spending his childhood years in a drug-ridden Baltimore neighborhood, Moore's family moved to the South Bronx shortly after his father's death. Following a brush with the law, his mother enrolled him in a military academy. Later, he became a college football Hall of Famer, Rhodes Scholar, decorated Army combat veteran and business leader. Meanwhile, another Wes Moore, who grew up in the same part of town under similar circumstances, ended up a convicted felon serving a life sentence for murder.
Intrigued by their divergent paths, Moore wrote his imprisoned counterpart a note. A month later, he received a response. "The letter I received was one of the most interesting and articulate letters I've ever received and it raised more questions ... The more I learned about this tragedy, the more I realized we had a lot of similarities and not just the same names," he said. Moore explored their differing outcomes in his novel which resonated with readers and led to a number of televised profiles.
Among the many points he made regarding health, Moore challenged the assertion that environment determines one's eventual success or failure in life. "We're not products of our environments, I think we're products of our expectations ... The expectations others have of you will eventually become the expectations you have for yourselves," he said. "If we look at a kid and the community they're from and say they're probably not going to make it, then kids have a funny way of making that happen, because we are a nation of self-fulfilling prophecies."
Regarding health, he maintained that communities need to hold themselves to higher expectations as well. "We can't have neighborhoods where it's acceptable to have a McDonalds as the only food outlet." Other issues Moore addressed included guns as a public health issue in light of the Aurora movie theater massacre. "The fact that it's easier for a child to get a gun than health care is a fundamental problem," he said. "This country has to better address gun laws ... I'm not talking about banning guns, but we need to be more careful about who can get weapons."
Health and the "me factor"
Dovetailing nicely with Wes Moore's rousing keynote, Friday's plenary discussion focused on personal responsibility and health. Moderated by Elizabeth Carger, a market researcher with Olson Zaltman Associates, the discussion dwelled on how to engage reluctant masses and those with opposing views on health and health care.
With "bridging the divides" a recurrent theme throughout the 2012 Symposium, Carger talked about the political divides impeding health policy. Carger was a project researcher of
"A New Way to Talk About the Social Determinants of Health." Produced for the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, the study shares how to develop more compelling, effective and persuasive messages that resonate across the political spectrum.
"Democrats believe the system is broken and that any one factor is not going to fix it," she said. On the other hand, Republicans tend to believe that "poor health comes from choosing bad paths and the inability to overcome obstacles." In short, Democrats believe the imbalance in health is unjust while Republicans believe that as long as there are differences in income there will be differences in health. Democrats believe equality should be the goal, while Republicans believe equality is an unrealistic and unfair goal. Democrats want to level the playing field, while Republicans would like to raise the playing field. "You have to sell your message to Republicans," Carger said. "In order to do that, it's critical to scrub the word 'equity' out of your language." A glossary of other terms to avoid is included in the study.
Ann E. Christiano, a professor of public-interest communications who also worked on the aforementioned study, offered eight tips for getting people to pay attention and make health a priority. They are: 1) Stop saying what you do. Focus on why you do it. 2) Become strategically empathetic. 3) Communicate in pictures. 4) Use the full palette of emotion. 5) Stop hinting. Tell people what you want them to do. 6) Tell stories like you mean it. 7) Remember that each person you communicate with is part of a larger social network. 8) Don't worry about whether your audience is as passionate about your issue as you are. Demanding moral conviction from everyone in your audience can be limiting. As a bonus tip, Christiano advised those in the conference room to "share their privilege." "You believe the issues you are taking on are surmountable," she said. "Understanding that change is possible can be the first and biggest step for everyone."
Sandeep Jauhar, MD, PhD, gave the Symposium audience some insights on attitudes about how personal responsibility (or lack thereof) drives up insurance premiums when people smoke, drink in excess or become obese. In doing so, he examined the statement, "I'm tired of paying for somebody else's stupidity," and why it resonates with so many Americans. "Americans don't want to pick up the tab for other people's personal habits," said Jauhar, author of the book, "Intern: A Doctor's Initiation." "We believe in personal responsibility." He noted that the call for "personal responsibility" in managing health transcends political lines. "We need to make people responsible in their own health, otherwise we increase risks," Jauhar said. He pointed out that smoking costs the American health care system $200 billion a year and obesity will soon become the No. 1 cause of death with 300,000 American deaths annually. Jauhar also highlighted some notable findings regarding personal responsibility and insurance coverage. Among them: A health insurance experiment from RAND Corp. that showed people spend more on health care when they have no-deductible health insurance policies. "When health care is perceived as free, patients will generally use more of it," he said. In West Virginia, an experiment reduced Medicaid benefits for recipients who didn't participate in a wellness program. Jauhar regarded that experiment as a "failure" since only 15 percent of the recipients took part and the program did not deter non-healthy behavior. What the program did not take into account were "real life barriers" to compliance such as lack of transportation or child care.
Concluding the discussion, Chris Waugh, director and co-founder of IDEO's Food & Beverage practice, talked about how to make health more interesting and engaging. Waugh works with businesses to design innovative approaches to move conversation to action. Much of the time, that can be done by taking the word "health" out of the equation. He offered an example of worksite cooking classes hosted by IDEO. "If you start by saying you should learn to cook healthy food because it's good for you, that's a terrible invitation," he said. "'Health' is an invitation without a party." On the other hand, an employer that offers free cooking classes that emphasize that cooking makes one attractive to romantic prospects gets more participation and better results. As for making health a bigger priority among kids, Waugh suggested reframing physical activity as play over exercise. "We have to make exercise more functional," he said, noting that "walkability" is becoming a more important factor in real estate purchases than square footage.
Biographies of today's plenary speakers at the Colorado Health Symposium are available online.
Symposium odds and ends
Friday's session closed with a bang as Anne Warhover, president and CEO of the Colorado Health Foundation announced that the Colorado Health Insurance Cooperative Inc. (CO-OP) will receive a $69 million loan from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services to begin work on a statewide nonprofit health insurance CO-OP. Read more about it in this news release ... The Symposium's first pedometer challenge was a rousing success. Provided with a pedometer upon arrival, Symposium attendees worked collectively toward the challenge of taking 1.2 million steps (representing the number of Coloradan children). Warhover threw participants a curve ball when she doubled the goal on the second day. With help from Keystone's banquet staff, participants surpassed the goal, closing the event with 2.6 million steps. For meeting the goal, the Foundation will donate $25,000 to Feeding Colorado, an association of five Feeding America food banks.
Catch up with the Symposium online
For those who missed some or the entire Symposium, plenary sessions (and Wednesday's interactive debate) are available via Ustream.
You also can keep up through other social media channels including blogs, and frequent postings on Facebook and Twitter. Look out for announcements on our Health Symposium Twitter stream using the #12CHS hashtag.
Next up: The 2013 Colorado Health Symposium
Mark your calendars for the 2013 Colorado Health Symposium, Aug. 7-9, 2013 in Keystone, Colo. See you there!